Not at all Cornish Pasties


As a family we went to Devon every summer for two weeks. Yes,  Children of the Modern age, back in the 1970s/80s you had one holiday a year, to the same self-catering place, with no TV , intermittent hot water. And you loved it and were grateful.

Nick was spending his two weeks in similar circumstances in Cornwall  the next county down, with a six-hour journey in a three-wheeler from Derbyshire,  they couldn’t listen to music because his dad needed to “hear” the engine . The highlight of the journey was apparently  stopping off at the Ginsters Factory for bags of Cornish pasties . He  swears their pasties in the 1970/80s were fantastic.

Perhaps if I had indulged as a child I might have tried pasties them sooner but the soggy looking envelopes prevalent in  corner shop chilller cabinets always looked like they were filled with something predigested . So it was not until my  twenties and  ravenous after a day of falling off surfboards in St Ives that I bought my first pasty.

It started well, heavy , hot from the oven with flaky pastry and no sooner had a started biting in and  I was planning a second and third purchase ( only the prospect of a pasty bulging wetsuit prevented me) . I  couldn’t believe  how  the simplest of fillings , potato , onion,  swede , beef and black pepper to season could taste so good.  Since then on holidays in Cornwall I always make sure to pick up a pastie for a lunch on the beach or walking. I like how  tiny shops sell their own versions and you have to get them early or they sell out

Last week in what has been described by the Cornish Pasty Association, as a “guarantee of quality”  the European Commission assigned   Cornish Pasties with Protected Geographical Indication (PGI) . Effectively meaning EU producers may only label pasties as Cornish if they made within the specific geographical area of  Cornwall  and with features or qualities attributable to that area.

The features according to the Cornish Pasty association are

  • a distinctive D shape and is crimped onone side, never on top.
  • texture of the filling is chunky, made up of uncooked minced or roughly cut chunks of beef (not less than 12.5%),
  • swede, potato, onion with a light seasoning.
  • pastry casing is golden in colour, savoury, glazed with milk or egg and robust enough to retain its shape throughout the cooking and cooling process without splitting or cracking.
  • pasty is slow-baked and no artificial flavourings or additives must be used.

The Cornish Pasties application for   PGI is  derived from historial records attributing  Cornish Tin minors with developing pasties to take  down the Cornish Tin mines in the 1800s.

“The crust (crimped edge) was used as a handle which was then discarded due to the high levels of arsenic in many of the tin mines. The pastry case insulated the contents and was durable enough to survive while its wholesome, nourishing ingredients provided enough sustenance to see the workers through their long and arduous days.” PGI Cornish Pasty application

This designation is not yet final with full registration of the PGI approval should be given in the next week or so. The recent announcement is  not without some controversy award winning Devon producers Chunk of Devon who say the PGI only specifies where it is produced rather than a mark of quality.

“When champagne ….got its famous status they had a list of quality obsessed rules … the pasty rules are simply make it here. You can therefore rock up with a bit of dosh,set up a shed, buy in cheap imported meat and veg, a handful of flavour enhancers, use a naff margarine pastry  and hey ho a Cornish Pasty….. far removed from the iconic scoff that is the real thing! ” Chunk of Devon Website

The PGI Cornish Pasty application is a little more poetic .

“Although there is no requirement for the raw ingredients to be sourced from within Cornwall in practice much of it continues to be supplied by local farmers thus continuing the long established symbiotic relationship between Cornish farmer and Cornish baker. “

It might sound like a case of sour grapes but sadly Chunk of Devon are entirely correct , where something it produced is not neccessarily a mark of quality especially if the place designated is over 1000 square miles.

In fact champagne has to adhere to more specific rules since it is registered as a  PDO (Protected Designation of Origin) this designation term used to describe foodstuffs which are produced, processed and prepared in a given geographical area using recognised know-how. The British example is  Stilton Cheese can only be made in Derbyshire, Leicestershire and Nottinghamshire from local milk and dairies are licencnsed in it’s production.  The link with the area is therefore stronger for PDOs.

A PGI requires a link with the area only in  at least one of the stages of production, processing or preparation (Melton Mowbray Pork Pies – Melton Mowbray. The small town of Melton Mowbray would be over-run with pigs if all the pork required came from this city ).

You will also still be able to get your pasties from a freindly station or town centre outlet trucked up from Cornwall ,

Assembly of the pasties in preparation for baking must take place in the designated area. The actual baking does not have to be done within the geographical area, it is possible to send the finished but unbaked and/or frozen pasties to bakers or other outlets outside the area where they can be baked in ovens for consumption.” PGI Cornish Pasty application  

Other items currently under publication include PDOs for Native Shetland Wood and PGIs for Welsh Beef and Lamb, Lough Neagh Eel.

My personal view is  that marketeers know people have got a bit hung up on awards ,desginations and labels, and they exploit it for a premium rarely of benefit to small local producers .   It is best to keep and enquiring mind , get to know local producers and read the small print .

I’ve made some not at all Cornish Pasties right down to the lack of side crimp but they were lovely  made mine with beef from Blackbrook Longhorns beef (they are 15 miles from me and regulars at my local  market grilling gorgeous burgers) . Potatoes , onions  swede from the vegebox . I used a mix of lard and butter which gives a lovely flaky texture on baking. Anyway that’s the science bit now onto the tasty pasty bit.


Not at all Cornish Pasties

Makes 6


125g chilled and diced butter
125g lard
500g plain flour , plus extra to roll out
Pinch of salt
1 egg , beaten


350g stweing beef e.g shin/leg
1 large onion , finely chopped
2 medium potatoes , peeled, thinly sliced
175g swedes , peeled, finely diced
1 tbsp freshly ground black pepper
1/2 tsp salt

1.Using a food processor , pulse the  butter and lard into the flour with a pinch of salt
2. Blend in 6 tbsp cold water to make a firm dough. and place in the fridge for 20minutes to chill
3. Heat oven to 220degC
4. Mix together the filling ingredients. Divide the dough into 6
5.  Roll out each piece of dough on a lightly floured surface until large enough to make a round about 20cm across – use a plate to trim it to shape.
6. Firmly pack a sixth of the filling into the centre of the disc,  leaving a margin at each end.
7. Brush the pastry all the way round the edge with beaten egg, carefully draw up both sides so that they meet at the top, then pinch them together to seal.
8. Lift onto a non-stick baking tray and brush with the remaining egg to glaze.
9. Bake for 10 mins, then lower oven to 180C/fan 160C/gas 4 and cook for 45 mins more until golden.


They were delicious and the builders agreed, once you have made a batch you can freeze them before baking and bake from frozen, just allow an extra 15 minutes at the end .

More recipes from Girl Interrupted Eating

Pork PieChard and Cheese Tart by you.Butternut Squash and Leek Quiche


  1. I first had cornish pasties in Manchester/London with my then-boyfriend who got them for our train journey. They were incredible and I miss them so much. I cannot find nice pasties in my part of Canada. Thanks for the recipe! I must try them. My favourite was the cheese and mushroom from the West Cornwall Pasty Company (I think that was the kiosk in Euston).

  2. Great post and bang on the mark. It is great that the EU allows passionate local producers to register and protect food tradition. There are too many products that have been abused such as the Cumberland sausage. I doubt, however that there are few foods which attract as much passion as the Cornish pasty. In my teens, an old Scout master of mine had an argument in a chip shop because he had found carrots in the pasty. You only have to visit the motorway services to see that this is only the start of the abuse.

  3. I am no longer certain the place you’re getting your information, but great topic. I needs to spend a while learning more or working out more. Thank you for magnificent info I was on the lookout for this info for my mission.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s